Atul Gawande recently (3.15.14) discussed Time Out and implementation.
The point of the Time Out Project is to provide potential solutions to implement Time Out powerfully and effectively.
Quote from Gawande article:
“My suspicion is that a government mandate without a serious effort to change the culture and practice of surgical teams results in limited change and weak, if any, reduction in mortality.
But it’s hard to know from the Ontario study. Without measuring actual compliance with using the checklist, it’s like running a drug trial without knowing if the patients actually took the drug.
Perhaps, however, this study will prompt greater attention to a fundamentally important question for health care reform broadly: how you implement an even simple change in systems that reduces errors and mortality – like a checklist.
For there is one thing we know for sure: if you don’t use it, it doesn’t work.”
Here’s Dr. Cliff Stermer and I, filming the first-ever Woodhull Hospital Medicine Time Out training video! The Time Out, or safety checklists designed to check for correct patient, procedure, site and side, is crucial to avoiding error, like infection, complications, even death. Yet it’s not ingrained in medicine culture, as it is in surgery.
Dr. Edward Fishkin and I wrote the script, with Jon Ehinger, director of this film, in February 2013. So exciting to finally have this – and fun to film with the medical students and staff!
We are showing this video to staff on the floor and in the OR immediately before they conduct their procedures, “on the spot,” as part of the Time Out Project research.
Woodhull Hospital’s Time Out Project, led by Edward Fishkin MD and Minda Aguhob M.Ed., developed this video in Winter 2013 to train staff about how to properly conduct Time Out outside of the operating room. This video is part of a series intended to improve training and implementation of safety checklists throughout Woodhull.
Dr. Farrokh Farrokhi of Virginia Mason Medical Center in Seattle explains why he, a neurosurgeon, finds Time Out — or pre-surgical safety checklists designed to check correct patient, procedure, side, etc. — very useful. He is being interviewed by myself, Minda Aguhob, MEd, in front of my poster on the Time Out project at the 2012 Institute for Healthcare Improvement National Forum.
We discussed the value of “Time Out” pre-procedure safety checklists, as a way for the surgeon to effectively manage the surgical team in the OR. We even talk about it as a practice that develops empathy and soothing of strong emotions – characteristics associated with great doctors.
Dr. Farrokhi and myself met while presenting posters at the 2012 IHI National Forum storyboard session. Hisand Dr. Allison Porter’s poster discusses adaptation of safety checklists to local culture in the OR, and my poster with Drs. Edward Fishkin and Saida Karimova presented baseline Time Out performance data in the OR, ICU, GI Clinic and ER. We will test training techniques at Woodhull this year, such as “on-the-spot” training videos, or simulations, in the OR and medicine floors to learn what helps improve Time Out more effectively.
The Time Out Project’s Dec 2012 IHI Poster was set up under the “Innovate” section at the IHI National Forum 2012 poster session: IHI Storyboards (requires login) http://app.ihi.org/events/viewposterboard.aspx?EventId=2206
Aaron Oswald, a premedical student from Cornell University and student in the Urban Semester program during Summer 2012, wrote the following narrative about his observations of Time Outs at Woodhull:
Regardless of official policies and guidelines, the tacit culture in the hospital remains the strongest force in determining whether Time Outs will be conducted. These understandings exist within a strong hierarchy, and thus are determined primarily by physicians. With or without an attending physician, team members often don’t feel comfortable acting contrary to the status quo, even if that means following official policies.
The Time Out Project provides premedical and medical students the opportunity to educate staff about Time Outs in a non-threatening way. By pitching a research study that promises not to judge individuals, I was able to persuade staff to think about their success with safety measures. Regardless, a student observer advocating for Time Outs is put in an awkward position, where he or she must play both bureaucratic and scholarly roles. Premedical and medical students generally take only scholarly roles, discussing but never openly challenging providers. Therefore, an instant baseline of tension develops when providers realize their student is observing and advocating for Time Outs. Yet, when the study is appropriately communicated to staff, they often respond positively, and are willing to work with students to incorporate Time Outs into their practice.
Aaron makes a couple very good points, about Time Out and what really determines whether these checklists are done. Last year, the Washington Post reported that despite the evidence base on the efficacy of Time Out, e.g. surgical safety checklists, to prevent error, there has been virtually no improvement in wrong-site surgeries, and the Joint Commission states that based on state data, the rate of wrong-site surgeries is 40 a week (June 2011). Mark Chassin, a former New York state health commissioner and since 2008 president of the Joint Commission, said he thinks such errors are growing in part because of increased time pressures, and involves changing the culture of hospitals and getting doctors to follow standardized procedures and work in teams. Doctors typically prize their autonomy, resist checklists and underestimate their propensity for error.
Aaron also addresses the unique role of students in this project. I believe that students are an underutilized resource in hospitals, and in the Time Out project we place them in a challenging situation; yet these students, future leaders in quality, have performed beautifully in spite of the challenges! As a result, we have about 80 observations of Time Out, and an ongoing dialogue that has been created and will expand, beginning with these observations in the clinical setting.
The Time Out project aims to create culture change, which includes learning how to implement Time Out effectively. This includes an acknowledgement of how things are done now – through observations of Time Out in the current environment – and then testing out strategies. Thus, we are rolling out two types of Time Out trainings – video and simulation – in the clinical setting. These trainings are designed to be quick and on-the-spot. We have just trained a new class of Cornell Urban Semester students this week to be observers.
And we look forward to training our next class of awesome St. George’s University medical students in this work as well! These medical students are veterans, since they — and their previous classes of peers — have been observing Time Out at Woodhull, one class after another, since February 2010.
Looking forward to seeing what this year’s observations and training will bring.
Artist Access. Kids’ Ride Club. Creative Arts Therapy. The Time Out Project.
These are all projects that began at Woodhull Hospital. Woodhull is a place for innovation-like the Artist Access program, where you can trade art for healthcare dollars. This was the brainchild of Edward Fishkin MD, Woodhull’s Medical Director.
Therapist-filmmaker Jon Ehinger, a creative arts therapist at Woodhull, who is passionate about the surrounding Brooklyn community we serve (a meeting of 4 major neighborhoods: Bushwick, Williamsburg, and Greenpoint) is doing innovative therapy using film. He is helping us with training videos for the Time Out project.
Ed Fishkin & I met cycling, thus the Time Out Project was born. After I did an informational interview with him, looking to use my education research background for healthcare, he told me about Time Out.
We developed a research study proposal that was further developed at the 2010 AMSA Patient Safety & Quality Leadership Institute with David Nash of Jefferson School of Population Health. He thought it was a crazy idea. But 2 weeks later, we launched it at Woodhull. And here we are, still going strong almost three years later. In 2012, we received a training grant from Cardinal Health and IHI.
The Time Out Project’s first training video was developed in 2012 at Woodhull Hospital with Ed Fishkin, myself, Saida Karimova & Jon Ehinger.
Can researchers be part of culture change?
Researchers can – by just observing. (Hawthorne effect, yes, may as well work with it…)
Researchers don’t focus enough on how to put things into practice.
-Caroline Clancy, opening remarks at AHRQ Conference 2012.
We need disruptive innovation in tools – they should drive quality up, take cost down. -Reed Tuckson, closing remarks at AHRQ Conference 2012
Time Outs, e.g., safety checklists, are a simple, free tool to ensure safety, an innovation supported by Atul Gawande and Haynes’ WHO research study that reduces deaths due to error by 50%, complications by 30% (NEJM 2009).
The Time Out Project at Woodhull Hospital in Brooklyn, NY,, which I developed and initiated with Woodhull Medical Director Dr. Edward Fishkin, with the support of Dr. David Nash at Jefferson School of Population Health, AMSA, and the Patient Safety and Quality Leadership Institute led by Marina Zeltser, Boris Rosenfeld and myself, is about how to put safety checklists into practice, effectively.
The project includes the following work that addresses individual, systemic, and education issues so we can shift the culture of safety:
1. An NYU IRB-approved research study designed to understand the successes and failures of the hospital’s implementation and training of Time Outs. We are studying not only how well Time Outs are conducted in the OR, ICU, GI Clinic and ED, but also ways to more effectively train staff (beyond a one-time video viewed at the beginning of the year). We observe staff conducting Time Out using videotaped and written observations. We now have about 60 observations, and plan to gather another 60+ this coming year, incorporating “on-the-spot” video or simulation training.
2. Advocacy projects, such as:
- The development of a housestaff safety council for residents to communicate with senior management around safety issues. See the below post about the Housestaff Safety Council I worked with Dr Fishkin, Chermain Cross, Senior Associate Director, and Dr. Rafael Hernandez, then PGY-3 / CIR-SEIU-Woodhull president, to launch.
- Training the Time Out medical and pre-medical student observers to become “quality consultants.” The Time Out Project provides premedical and medical students the opportunity to serve as a resource to staff who request info about how to conduct Time Outs. For the past year, the Time Out observations provide a way to regularly communicate with staff to think about their success with safety measures. While tension may develop when providers realize they are being observed, observers found staff often respond positively when the study is appropriately communicated to staff; and they are willing to work with students to incorporate Time Outs into their practice.
3. Video projects. We are developing a series of training videos that can be viewed before procedures requiring Time Out, for the operating room and the medicine departments, to improve safety and how staff communicate through the Time Out. Here is our first one, for training at grand rounds.
4. Writing projects. Not only will we contribute to the research base on best practices for checklist implementation, but we will also regularly document our journey to positively shift the culture of safety at Woodhull so others can learn from our experience.
This project is all about communication.
We’ve found, so far, that there is a growing awareness of Time Out and how to best conduct them, at Woodhull. Stay tuned, as we will continue to report our learnings.
(above post includes writing from Aaron Oswald, Cornell University Urban Semester Program, Summer 2012 Time Out observer)